My #metoo moment
Historical accusations of sexual impropriety are trending. Harvey Weinstein is an awful sexual predator who is in the news daily. Turns out his pro Zionist position included hiring Israeli intelligence to spy on his accusers to discredit them. Although Harvey’s opportunistic casting couch impropriety is none of my business, my curiosity in this subject is the legal landscape in which what constitutes sexual offenses has shifted. Not that long ago we were voting for a President who openly admitted his rapey past. Instead of being disgusted, as we were with Harvey, who was jailed, instead we celebrated Trump and elected him as president.
I wonder when does sexual inappropriateness become illegal. How credible is the reporting of historic sexual offenses, sometimes 30 years in the past, when allegations appear without evidence as a money making opportunity. Is it conduct that devalues the very serious and unacceptable predatory nature of powerful people using their status to inappropriately exploit women. Even when it falls below the legal bar of rape. Why did Harvey go to Jail and Donald went to the White House?
In the spirit of sharing, I am reminded of my own experience of non consensual sexy time, in which I admit from the outset, I would definitely have said yes had any invitation preceded the action.
This particular event, not my first #metoo tale, happened some time in 1992. In a splendid Victorian manor house in the mid east of England where I was attending the wedding of the lawyer/owner of the distribution company representing my music. A good friend, much admired by many musicians, and an influential power in London’s music business marrying a (very pretty) Publisher.
My wedding gift on the occasion of this lovely marriage between two music biz types was a 1954 release of Elvis Presley’s ‘That’s alright mama‘. On a 78 RPM vinyl disc, a collectible in-the-sleeve original copy that might be worth some money one day. I thought, a nice gift for a musical friend with expensive tastes. My well intentioned joke was “stay together long enough and this will be worth some money.”
I was single at the time. I attended this overnight wedding on my own, staying overnight at a guest hotel nearby, some two hours drive North from London.
Being a music industry wedding, almost all the 200+ guests were in the music business. The reception was impeccably arranged, a bit like a music venue concert. A big marquee was set up in the big garden, with a professional sound stage and a big PA, on which a variety of world class acts took a Turn. Acts who were signed to the distribution company, many of whom were Irish. This was a splendid wedding party concert where I got to see famous artists I had not met before. I was having a blast.
One of the star turns that day was a leading Irish singer. I had never met her but knew of her international reputation and attractive record covers. Hers was the voice of a maestro, not only in singing technique, but in the masterful way she interpreted Irish traditional music. I noticed she was revered by all who approached her. That star quality where you don’t just go over and say Hi.
Being frank, as a slightly starstruck Andrew, while I stood in the marquee at side of stage listening to her sing, I was overwhelmed by her mastery of that Irish-emotion singing. She ended her short set with ‘Song for Ireland’. I had never heard that song before. You could have heard a pin drop when she sang it. Shivers ran down my spine. The best I had ever heard in that Irish style of emotional fire paper siren song, despite my lifelong aversion to vibrato. She could get away with that. She could get away with anything when she sang that song.
I was stood to one side of the stage area watching, with a champagne flute in hand, dressed, uncharacteristically in a grey suit (Hugo Boss) with a white shirt (Armani) out of respect for my upmarket, smart hosts.
At the time I weighed 65 kg. Pretty thin and fit and sporting an abundance of hair. I was mesmerized by that moment. Vulnerable as any one would be caught up in a superior artistic performance of Irish musical excellence. Her song ended. An emotional eulogy for Ireland that left the audience drained and ecstatic. I was enthralled.
The applause and praise was ringing loud as she turned to leave the stage, walking straight past me. Whereupon, she stopped, looked at me, and without so much as a ‘by your leave‘, placed two hands behind my neck and kissed me.
Not a peck on the cheek kiss. A full blown, leave it to your imagination version of a deep and meaningful kiss. Lasting, probably, many seconds, although I have no way of knowing as time appeared to stand still. An electrifying moment. I was not expecting that.
I have no further recollection from the remainder of that wedding party. I never saw her again. But the moment lingered in my memory for many years, to be triggered when reading the current trending array of #MeToo posts.
What was wrong with me. Why did I just let someone in a position of power have their way with me without demanding the opportunity to first give consent. I just stood back and thought of Greece. Her assumption that I was available to be used and discarded turned out to be right. Imagine how I felt about it afterwards?
My take on the sensibility of uninvited intimacy that is not first subject to consensual agreement allowing the option to say NO, that excludes any aspect of rape or attempted rape in the Trump style is;
The only thing worse than being hit on without prior consent, is not ever being hit on.
At no point until the #MeToo movement did I imagine that any part of that meeting might be either inappropriate or legally actionable. Although, on paper, had the situation reversed in a gender flip, I wonder if a monetary inducement might reinvent any similar experience.
Now we see enormous press demand for historical complaints of sexual abuse remembered 25 years later. Is it because click bait has monetized the genre. There is a significant difference between sexual abuse and spontaneous flirtation in which the flirted with can always just say no at the time. If that no does not mean no, then its rape, and a matter for the law. Then and there. Why would anyone wait 25 years to report a sexual offense? Why would anyone be interested in an old and unsubstantiable claim that was not worth mention when it happened. Unless you follow the money.
The transactional element in which Rich old men romance ambitious younger women, who in many cases have historically related interest to monetary payment in love-for-sale, is a marriage made in heaven. Wrinkly old Murdoch still attracts attractive women in his 90’s.
My conclusion is;
We should not overthink what constitutes sexual impropriety in the conduct of others. What happens between two people when it is not reported as rape, like, for example, Stormy Daniels being hit on by Donald Trump, is often best left between the two people. Especially when 25 years have passed before the allegation is raised in a court that can never know ‘beyond all reasonable doubt’. Especially when there is a financial motive in ‘She said/He said’ litigation where no more than a ‘balance of probability’ metric can be applied in a court process that rewards the best liars.
Although I am a survivor of more than one woman flirting suggestively without first inviting my consent, I wont be instructing personal injury solicitors anytime soon.
__________________________________
My Retail Bookstore is here Andrew Brel Books (Amazon, Audible and Apple Books.)
Comments are closed, but trackbacks and pingbacks are open.